Adh-Dhahhaak said,
"This verse was revealed when members of the Banu Tameem delegation
were mocking the poor Companions like ‘Ammaar, Khabbaab, Bilaal, Suhayb,
Salmaan, and Saalim the slave of Abu Huthayfah because of their shabby
clothes. But there are other opinions as well. It was said that this
verse was revealed when ‘Ikrimah ibn Abu Jahl came to Madeenah as a
Muslim and the people there would call him the ‘Son of the pharaoh of
this Ummah’ whenever they saw him. So, he complained to the Prophet
(saws) and this verse was revealed. It was also said that this verse was
revealed when Thaabit ridiculed a man because of his mother in
Jahiliyyah and the man was disgraced."
Commenting on this verse, Al-Qurtubi, “Allah says here that those who believe in Him and in His Messenger (saws) should not ridicule other believers as they may be better than them. Also, women should not ridicule each other for the same reason.”
He also said, “Allah is referring here to all sorts of mockery in this prohibition for the believers. Hence, it is impermissible for any believer to mock another believer: either for being poor, or for a sin that he has committed, or for any other reason.”
Al-Qurtubi added, "In general, no one should dare to ridicule another person even if that person was shabby, handicapped or inarticulate, for that person may be more sincere or may have a purer heart than the one who is not shabby or handicapped or inarticulate. In this case, ridiculing such a person would be despising someone whom Allah has honored. The righteous predecessors were keen on avoiding this to the extent that ‘Amr ibn Shurahbeel said, “If I saw a man suckling a goat and laughed at him, I would fear that I might end up doing the same thing.” It was reported that ‘Abdullaah ibn Mas’ood said that affliction depends on what a person says. Hence, he said that if he mocked a dog, he would fear that he would be turned into a dog."
In his commentary on the verse: "But you took them in mockery to the point that they made you forget My remembrance, and you used to laugh at them." [23:110], Al-Qurtubi said that this verse is a warning against mocking, despising or ridiculing the weak and the needy to the point that it would make us forget remembering Allah and would thus keep us far from Him. In a Hadeeth on the authority of ‘Aa’ishah she said, “I said to the Prophet (saws) ‘It is enough for you that Safiyyah is such-and-such (meaning that she was short).’ The Prophet (saws) replied: ‘You have said a word that could adulterate the water of the sea if it were mixed with it.’” She also said, “I once imitated a man before him (ridiculing him) and He said: ‘I would never like to imitate anyone, even if I were to get such- and-such (a reward for it).’” [Abu Dawood and At-Tirmithi]
Another example is when Abu Tharr abused a man by calling his mother bad names, the Prophet (saws), said to him: “O Abu Tharr! Did you abuse him by calling his mother bad names? You still have some characteristics of Jaahiliyyah in you.” [Al-Bukhari]
In a Hadith on the authority of Umm Haani’ the Prophet (saws), said about the verse: "and commit in your meetings (every) evil." [29:29] that they used to despise and mock people. [Ahmad and At-Tirmithi]
The polytheists of Makkah like Abu Jahl, Al-Waleed ibn Al-Mughirah and their likes would mock ‘Ammaar, Suhayb, Bilaal and other poor believers; hence, Allah revealed the verse: "Indeed, those who committed crimes used to laugh at those who believed." [83:29]
It was said that ‘Ali was once walking with a number of Muslims and some hypocrites mocked them and they exchanged derisory glances. When they returned to their people, they said, “We have seen the bald one (i.e., ‘Ali) today.” Hence, the above mentioned verse was revealed before ‘Ali reached the Prophet (saws) to inform him of what had happened.
Sarcasm and Derision are Forms of Mockery
Sarcasm and derision are forms of mockery. An example of this is when one derides another for being poor, handicapped or for committing a sin. Moreover, calling people by offensive nicknames is another example of mockery. Al-Qurtubi said that calling people by offensive nicknames means calling them by names or attributes that they hate. Allah The Almighty generalized this rule and did not specify certain nicknames. It is impermissible for any Muslim to call his fellow brother by any nickname or any attribute that he hates. Allah Says: "O you who have believed, let not a people ridicule (another) people; perhaps they may be better than them." [49:11]
There are several stories as to the revelation of this verse. Anas and Ibn Zayd said that the above mentioned verse was revealed when some of the wives of the Prophet (saws), ridiculed Safiyyah for being short. It was also said that this verse was revealed when ‘Aa’ishah indicated by her hand to the Prophet (saws), that Safiyyah was short. Moreover, ‘Ikrimah and Ibn ‘Abbaas said that this verse was revealed when Safiyyah bint Huyayy said: “O Messenger of Allah! The women ridicule me and say to me, ‘O Jew...’” All these examples show that calling people by offensive nicknames is a form of mockery. They were mentioned in the verse as a way of mentioning the specific cases after the general rule in order to emphasize its importance. The scorner is the person who harms people by his tongue, while the mocker is the one who winks with his eyes. Ibn Kaysaan said that the scorner is the one who hurts others with bad words, while the mocker is the one who points to others with his eyes, his head and his eyebrows.
The Difference Between Mocking and Ridiculing
There are two differences between them. The first is that ridiculing can be done by deeds or words, whereas, mocking is done only by deeds. The second is that ridiculing is usually preceded by an act that causes its doer to be an object of ridicule, while mocking is not preceded by such an act. Mocking is usually accompanied by words that are uttered with a bad intention. It occurs when the person seems to be serious while he conceals joking. As-Saffareeni said, “Mocking people and ridiculing them are prohibited because Allah Says: "O you who have believed, let not a people ridicule (another) people; perhaps they may be better than them." [49:11] Moreover, the Prophet (saws) prohibited this in many Ahadith.”
Commenting on this verse, Al-Qurtubi, “Allah says here that those who believe in Him and in His Messenger (saws) should not ridicule other believers as they may be better than them. Also, women should not ridicule each other for the same reason.”
He also said, “Allah is referring here to all sorts of mockery in this prohibition for the believers. Hence, it is impermissible for any believer to mock another believer: either for being poor, or for a sin that he has committed, or for any other reason.”
Al-Qurtubi added, "In general, no one should dare to ridicule another person even if that person was shabby, handicapped or inarticulate, for that person may be more sincere or may have a purer heart than the one who is not shabby or handicapped or inarticulate. In this case, ridiculing such a person would be despising someone whom Allah has honored. The righteous predecessors were keen on avoiding this to the extent that ‘Amr ibn Shurahbeel said, “If I saw a man suckling a goat and laughed at him, I would fear that I might end up doing the same thing.” It was reported that ‘Abdullaah ibn Mas’ood said that affliction depends on what a person says. Hence, he said that if he mocked a dog, he would fear that he would be turned into a dog."
In his commentary on the verse: "But you took them in mockery to the point that they made you forget My remembrance, and you used to laugh at them." [23:110], Al-Qurtubi said that this verse is a warning against mocking, despising or ridiculing the weak and the needy to the point that it would make us forget remembering Allah and would thus keep us far from Him. In a Hadeeth on the authority of ‘Aa’ishah she said, “I said to the Prophet (saws) ‘It is enough for you that Safiyyah is such-and-such (meaning that she was short).’ The Prophet (saws) replied: ‘You have said a word that could adulterate the water of the sea if it were mixed with it.’” She also said, “I once imitated a man before him (ridiculing him) and He said: ‘I would never like to imitate anyone, even if I were to get such- and-such (a reward for it).’” [Abu Dawood and At-Tirmithi]
Another example is when Abu Tharr abused a man by calling his mother bad names, the Prophet (saws), said to him: “O Abu Tharr! Did you abuse him by calling his mother bad names? You still have some characteristics of Jaahiliyyah in you.” [Al-Bukhari]
In a Hadith on the authority of Umm Haani’ the Prophet (saws), said about the verse: "and commit in your meetings (every) evil." [29:29] that they used to despise and mock people. [Ahmad and At-Tirmithi]
The polytheists of Makkah like Abu Jahl, Al-Waleed ibn Al-Mughirah and their likes would mock ‘Ammaar, Suhayb, Bilaal and other poor believers; hence, Allah revealed the verse: "Indeed, those who committed crimes used to laugh at those who believed." [83:29]
It was said that ‘Ali was once walking with a number of Muslims and some hypocrites mocked them and they exchanged derisory glances. When they returned to their people, they said, “We have seen the bald one (i.e., ‘Ali) today.” Hence, the above mentioned verse was revealed before ‘Ali reached the Prophet (saws) to inform him of what had happened.
Sarcasm and Derision are Forms of Mockery
Sarcasm and derision are forms of mockery. An example of this is when one derides another for being poor, handicapped or for committing a sin. Moreover, calling people by offensive nicknames is another example of mockery. Al-Qurtubi said that calling people by offensive nicknames means calling them by names or attributes that they hate. Allah The Almighty generalized this rule and did not specify certain nicknames. It is impermissible for any Muslim to call his fellow brother by any nickname or any attribute that he hates. Allah Says: "O you who have believed, let not a people ridicule (another) people; perhaps they may be better than them." [49:11]
There are several stories as to the revelation of this verse. Anas and Ibn Zayd said that the above mentioned verse was revealed when some of the wives of the Prophet (saws), ridiculed Safiyyah for being short. It was also said that this verse was revealed when ‘Aa’ishah indicated by her hand to the Prophet (saws), that Safiyyah was short. Moreover, ‘Ikrimah and Ibn ‘Abbaas said that this verse was revealed when Safiyyah bint Huyayy said: “O Messenger of Allah! The women ridicule me and say to me, ‘O Jew...’” All these examples show that calling people by offensive nicknames is a form of mockery. They were mentioned in the verse as a way of mentioning the specific cases after the general rule in order to emphasize its importance. The scorner is the person who harms people by his tongue, while the mocker is the one who winks with his eyes. Ibn Kaysaan said that the scorner is the one who hurts others with bad words, while the mocker is the one who points to others with his eyes, his head and his eyebrows.
The Difference Between Mocking and Ridiculing
There are two differences between them. The first is that ridiculing can be done by deeds or words, whereas, mocking is done only by deeds. The second is that ridiculing is usually preceded by an act that causes its doer to be an object of ridicule, while mocking is not preceded by such an act. Mocking is usually accompanied by words that are uttered with a bad intention. It occurs when the person seems to be serious while he conceals joking. As-Saffareeni said, “Mocking people and ridiculing them are prohibited because Allah Says: "O you who have believed, let not a people ridicule (another) people; perhaps they may be better than them." [49:11] Moreover, the Prophet (saws) prohibited this in many Ahadith.”
Only those whose souls are impure because of arrogance and pride ridicule others. They endeavor to hurt others because of the feeling of superiority that runs in their diseased veins. Shaytaan ridiculed Aadam and said, “I am better than him” and so he became a loser. Had he thought carefully of the characteristics of Aadam he would have realized that Aadam was superior to him. Mockery is one of the diseases of Jahiliyyah that should be avoided, especially at times of conflict and disputes. It is one of the characteristics of the disbelievers and the hypocrites that leads to the disunity of the society. In fact, it is an overt violation of the Commands of Allah and it keeps one away from the pleasure of Allah. Moreover, it makes one forget to remember Allah and causes him to be inflicted with His punishment.
No comments:
Post a Comment